Participatory Budgeting: International and Russian Experience

The research is devoted to the modern enhancement of budget allocation effciency at the municipal level. Internationally, it is referred to as participatory budgeting. The subject of the research is the world and Russian experience of participatory budgeting and the effectiveness of such initiatives. The research objective is to determine the correlation between the international experience of public participation in the budget allocation and the program of initiative budgeting in the Russian Federation; based on this, to develop recommendations for improving the effciency of budget expenditures. The theoretical basis and the relationship between the concepts of “participatory budgeting” used to denote public participation abroad, and the “proactive budgeting” adopted in Russia have been considered. More than 30 international studies of participatory budgeting over the past 15 years have been analyzed. The aspects and effectiveness of the approaches have been highlighted. The best international and Russian experiences of participatory (initiative) budgeting, their characteristics and commitment to results have been identifed. As a result, the authors have presented a basic scheme to organize the participatory budgeting process, highlighting the stages, activities and criteria for the effectiveness of programs implemented within this approach. The initiative budgeting perspectives in Russia have been shown on the example of Yekaterinburg. Some recommendations have been given to enhance the implementation effciency. Among them are: infrastructural differences between the territories, expanding fnancial independence of municipalities in terms of initiative budgeting, building a system of representatives of local communities. It has been concluded that the initiative budgeting in the Russian Federation differs notably in its form from the international initiatives. The main difference is the requirement to the population and business to co-fnance projects. Some measures have been proposed to move gradually from the Russian participatory budgeting to the international standards, including: developing a methodology for project effciency evaluation, providing tax incentives, extensive use of information technology, and introducing the annual schedule of meetings and polls.

1. Zubarevich N. V. Social differentiation of regions and cities. Pro et Contra. 2012; (4–5):135–152. (In Russ.).

2. Gorshkov M. K., Tikhonova N. E. The middle class as a social base for ensuring Russia’s competitiveness. Rossiya reformiruyushchayasya. 2005;(5):10–43. (In Russ.).

3. Marquetti A. Participação e Redistribuição: o Orçamento Participativo em Porto Alegre. In: Avritzer L., Navarro Z., eds. A inovação democrática no Brasil. São Paulo: Cortez; 2003:129–156.

4. Marquetti A., Bêrni D. Democracia Participativa, Performance Fiscal e Distribuição: a evidência dos municípios gaúchos. 2006. URL: https://www.fee.rs.gov.br/3eeg/Artigos/m14t02.pdf (accessed on 04.12.2018).

5. Reiter B. Participatory budgeting in Brazil: Contestation, cooperation, and accountability. Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions. 2009;22(1):165–168. DOI: 10.1111/j.1468–0491.2008.01426_6.x

6. Spada P. The effects of participatory democracy on political competition: The case of Brazilian participatory budgeting. APSA 2010 Annual Meeting Paper. 2010.

7. Gonçalves S. The effects of participatory budgeting on municipal expenditures and infant mortality in Brazil. World Development. 2014;(53):94–110. DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.01.009

8. Tsurkan M. V. Approaches to the definition of “participatory budgeting”. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2016;(1):67–71. (In Russ.).

9. Vagin V.V., Shapovalova N. A. The state of initiative budgeting in the Russian Federation: New trends and opportunities for development. Nauchno-issledovatel’skii finansovyi institut. Finansovyi zhurnal = Financial Research Institute. Financial Journal. 2018;(1):110–122. (In Russ.).

10. Vagin V. V., Gavrilova N. V., Shapovalova N. A. Initiative budgeting in Russia: Best practices and development trends. Nauchno-issledovatel’skii finansovyi institut. Finansovyi zhurnal = Financial Research Institute. Financial Journal. 2015;(4):94–103. (In Russ.).

11. Tsurkan M.V. The influence of participatory budgeting on the possibilities of development of territories. Srednerusskiy vestnik obshchestvennykh nauk = Central Russian Journal of Social Sciences. 2016;11(3):150– 158. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.12737/20396

12. Guz’ N. A. Participatory budgeting: Foreign experience and Russian practice. In: Gulyaev G. Yu., ed. Economic growth: Factors and mechanisms for sustainable development. Penza: Nauka i Prosveshchenie; 2017:66–81. (In Russ.).

13. Belenchuk A. A., Vagin V. V., Shul’ga I. E. Initiative budgeting as a tool to improve the efficiency of budget expenditures. Finansy = Finance. 2017;(8):10–21. (In Russ.).

14. Kadnikova T. G., Bokova T. A. Experience in implementing a program to support local initiatives. Finansy = Finance. 2017;(12):5–11. (In Russ.).

15. Vagin V. V., Shapovalova N. A., Gavrilova N. V. Analysis and systematization of the best Russian and foreign practice of involving citizens in budget initiatives. In: Initiative budgeting in the Russian Federation. Proc. All-Russ. conf. on initiative budgeting. Moscow; 2015:38–153. URL: http://www.nifi.ru/images/FILES/NEWS/21–221015_PB_conf/info_1.pdf (accessed on 15.06.2018). (In Russ.).

16. Khachatryan G., Shul’ga I., Gridin S., Sukhova A. Analytical note “Features of the Program for supporting world initiatives of the World Bank as an initiative for budgeting”. URL: https://adm.gov86.org/files/2017/finkom/05-informatsionnyy-byulleten-2016.pdf (accessed on 15.06.2018). (In Russ.).